If you have business income then it is very important to keep all your records in place, accounting for all your income sources. A businessman in Bengaluru found himself facing a tax notice after raids revealed cash in his locker which the Income Tax Department treated as unexplained.He eventually managed to get relief from the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. Here’s how the case unfolded.
What the case is about:
In 2018, the Income Tax Department conducted searches at a man’s residence and on his locker. During the operation, officials reportedly recovered Rs 3.9 crore in cash from the locker and another Rs 20 lakh from his house.The locker also contained jewellery valued at Rs 8.11 crore, including 751.52 grams of gold and 81.470 carats of diamonds. The jewellery was seized. Two watches worth Rs 16.25 lakh were also found in the locker and confiscated.Then, the Income Tax Assessing Officer (AO) in Bengaluru classified the total cash of Rs 4.1 crore as unexplained money under Section 69A and proposed taxing it at a special rate.The AO also asked the man to explain the source of the gold and diamond jewellery. Although he submitted an explanation, the officer was not satisfied with it and treated the jewellery as unexplained assets.The man pointed out that he had filed his income tax return (ITR), declaring income of Rs 19.26 crore, of which Rs 18.11 crore was reported as business income. He maintained that the cash recovered from his locker represented business earnings from earlier years through real estate commissions and money lending activities. According to him, the Rs 20 lakh found at his residence belonged to various family members.The AO rejected these submissions. Explaining the jewellery and diamonds, the man said their value, along with that of the watches, had already been included in the business income disclosed for the previous year. He further stated that the jewellery kept in the locker had been disclosed in the wealth tax returns filed by him and his family members.Regarding the two watches, the man submitted that his sister had gifted them to him and that their value had also been included in his ITR as business income. The AO, however, did not accept these explanations and classified the value of the jewellery and watches as unexplained investment under Section 69.
Do you think the Income Tax Department should automatically classify seized assets as black money?
3k+ users shared opinion today
5k+ users already voted today
3k+ users shared opinion today
Why ITAT Bangalore gave relief
The man subsequently filed an appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Bengaluru. On November 3, 2026, the tribunal ruled in his favour on the disputed assets, and asked the Income Tax Department to treat the seized cash as his business income.ITAT observed that the man had established that he earned business income and that the seized cash and jewellery had been reported as business income in the income tax return filed for Assessment Year 2019-20. The supporting documents and other evidence were also consistent with his explanation.The tribunal further noted that the Assessing Officer had not produced any additional material to establish that Amarlal earned income from other sources that could be assessed as unexplained money or investment under Sections 69 and 69A. Copies of the wealth tax returns filed by Amarlal and his family members supported his claim that the jewellery had been disclosed in earlier filings.Chartered Accountant Rohhit Saluja told ET that ITAT Bangalore held that cash and jewellery seized during an Income Tax Department search cannot automatically be classified as black money or unexplained investments under Sections 69 and 69A of the Income-tax Act, 1961.Saluja explained that the tribunal’s decision rested on five key considerations.First, the man had explained the nature of the seized cash in his statement recorded under Section 132(4).Second, his audited financial statements and income tax returns showed that business activities were his primary source of income.Third, the cash and jewellery recovered during the search had been accounted for as business income for the relevant assessment year.Fourth, his wealth tax returns for Assessment Year 2015-16 showed that he had disclosed jewellery in earlier years.Fifth, he had submitted a notarised affidavit of withdrawal on July 23, 2018, just three days after the search.According to Saluja, the Assessing Officer had not produced independent evidence to establish that the seized assets came from sources other than Amarlal’s business activities.On this basis, the ITAT Bengaluru Bench held that the assets should be treated as business income and taxed at the applicable regular rates, rather than the special rate prescribed under Section 115BBE. The appeal was consequently allowed.




